data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/05632/0563241758a17d9f7c05802671a33a76df507926" alt=""
It's time for another best of 2018 list! This week we look at the best performances of the year. And there will be quite a lot of surprises on that list. So here we go:
Honorable mention: QUEEN Olivia as her fabulous self in Widows and Game Night
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4d71b/4d71b5e702326ede37d3baf35048f62d69b32b40" alt=""
10. Melissa McCarthy as Lee Israel in Can You Ever Forgive Me?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4900c/4900c054717798b720bc3e598732af49b9f9c2f8" alt=""
McCarthy has been one of my favorite actresses for a while now. While she is best known for her comedy performances she always adds so much heart to her work - Bridesmaids' most wonderful moment was when she was lifting Annie's spirits, in Spy she managed to make us feel her heartbreak over unrequited love and in The Heat over how much she cared about her family and her new co-worker (the film's ending is so lovely!). In Can You Ever Forgive Me? Melissa gets to play a more serious part but she does it with her usual bravura. She is the best in the quiet moments - like when she is heartbroken after her cat passes away or when she is enjoying the music in a bar, on her own, with a smile on her face. Because of how sincere and natural she is in her work her characters never feel like caricatures.
9. Christian Bale as Dick Cheney in Vice
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3576d/3576d565a441fcec3899154d6a71221ea9ce8e66" alt=""
8. Sam Elliott as Bobby Maine in A Star is Born
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e602d/e602db21d47ad1ff283e0ae77edd557d92270e85" alt=""
7. Emma Stone as Abigail in The Favourite
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8fefb/8fefb478410aa11de96606d7263b45eef62f6c85" alt=""
Emma Stone was hugely surprising in Yorgos Lanthimos' latest. Her Abigail is the most fascinating character of the year - was she always devious or was it the side affect of the power she gained? Stone adds a lot of nuance to a character that could easily be a caricature - a single tear when she burns the letter, suggesting remorse, a genuine look of devastation when she hears about Anne's tragedy. She makes Abigail so hard to figure out and in that so hugely entertaining to watch.
6. Lady Gaga as Ally in A Star is Born
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc6aa/cc6aa73c62a4cde41258bf7c05c5446d85809bf8" alt=""
For a long time people thought Bradley Cooper's A Star is Born is going to be a disaster, even assuming Lady Gaga will win Razzie for it. And here we are, with Gaga who would be sure to win major awards had it not been for Glenn Close's "overdue" narrative. Gaga, who is anything but shy in real life, makes her Ally into slightly sheepish on the outside but very confident on the inside person, who we watch grow, become happy and then heartbroken. Gaga's Ally always feels like someone real, someone we both admire and like. And despite some of the script's shortcomings her transformation from shy girl who was too afraid to perform as herself into a superstar who is unaware of betraying her own identity and then finding it at last in the end is believable thanks to Gaga's acting.
5. Tom Hardy as Eddie Brock in Venom
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44396/443964eaa1c24173a56d2cd9f19e97cf4466818c" alt=""
4. Olivia Colman as Queen Anne in The Favourite
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d6b37/d6b37e2fbb41984256802d125ba3d58d96340ff3" alt=""
3. Blake Lively as Emily Nelson in A Simple Favor
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d9761/d9761df9621c042ae2a502c888e06ce8151fe6bd" alt=""
2. Ethan Hawke as Ernst Toller in First Reformed
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ce86e/ce86e193e2b6242f64f47f9a10d69c6645f04756" alt=""
Ethan Hawke is the aching heart and the torn apart soul of the remarkable First Reformed. As excellent as the script is the whole movie depends on Hawke's ability to make his character both likable and suspicious to the audience. We feel for him, we want him to be all right but we are also never sure what he is doing to do and in spite of our knowledge that this is a good man - Hawke entirely succeeds in convincing us of that - we never know what he will end up being capable of.
1. Bradley Cooper as Jackson Maine in A Star is Born
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc23c/cc23c9ea4cd204282989140febf0737bc3a41f9c" alt=""
Bradley Cooper has been giving wonderful performances for a while now, capturing the audiences with his natural charisma. But he was never better than he was here - as broken Jackson. Cooper makes his character likable and desirable but he doesn't shy away from showing the ugly side. Cooper changed his walk and his voice for this role but it never feels like a gimmick. Then there's also the fact he genuinely has a great voice and gave us so many wonderful songs here AND that he directed the movie. But even if you take all of that away, what he did here is he created a performance that is memorable and touches your heart. You care about him. And you feel just like Bobby did, because you know he won't be saved.
Lively was so good in A Simple Favor and I had never thought much of her before that. I love seeing Olivia and Bradley so high on the list as those were great performances. Hardy too, because Venom was so much fun.
ReplyDeleteAnd YES for an Olivia mention!
I really hope she gets to be in more good stuff, she is very charismatic! She may actually be the more versatile person in her marriage :)
DeleteI was not expecting to see Hardy lol he was awesome in Venom though!
ReplyDeleteI saw Can You Ever Forgive Me? yesterday and I absolutely adored McCarthy's performance.
YEY! Her and Richard E. Grant were both so great in that film!
DeleteAwesome list! There's a few I still have to see like Can You Ever Forgive Me and Vice. A Star Is Born would have not been the same without Sam. Totally agree about Tom Hardy in Venom, obviously. lol Emma was unforgettably devious and vulnerable in The Favourite - definitely one of my favorites of hers. Loved Blake Lively in A Simple Favor. She did a wonderful job capturing what a mind**** her character is.
ReplyDeleteYou probably know how I feel about that #1 pick! lol But I honestly didn't know BCoop would be number one, so I totally squealed and scared my mom. :P I learned the other day that Bradley used to be an alcoholic, and for him to make this film while being sober for 11 years, I think is a tremendous accomplishment alongside all of the things he did such as acting and directing for the first time. I feel like he stepped back from his past experiences, but also used/refined them for the film. It's one of his best, if not the best of his, so far.
I think you'll like both of those! Well maybe not Vice, but at least the performances there are fun :)
DeleteHaha, so glad you liked him being my number 1 so much! Yeah I know he is in recovery, it's even more impressive he decided to play that part that probably gave him some really unpleasant flashbacks to his own experiences
Tom Hardy was awesome as Venom, he was clearly having fun with the role and he was a big part of what made the movie fun.
ReplyDeleteLady Gaga and Bradley Cooper were amazing. Lady Gaga would have swept awards and competition might be tight between her and Olivia Coleman, who has a really big chance of winning as well. Still have to watch the others but been hearing great things about their performance.
I think Close is gonna win with both because of the 'overdue' narrative :/
DeleteOh, definitely! If she wasn't in competition, Lady Gaga and Olivia Coleman would be in tight competition with each other.
DeleteYes! I'm glad Colman at least won BAFTA last night
Deleteyou are spoiling us, this list is fantastic. will have to check out 'can you ever forgive me?' because mc carthy's performance makes me curious!
ReplyDeletealso same on lady gaga, just saw the netflix doc and she's so different in real life! some people thought she wasn't really acting but that just levels up her performance in 'a star is born'!
Yes, watch it! It's a very good movie and both McCarthy and Grant are great!
DeleteI still need to see that Gaga documentary
Agree about Lady Gaga, what makes her performance impressive is she plays a somewhat shy person and Gaga really isn't in real life. That's hard to do with the cameras rolling.
ReplyDeleteI was wondering if I should check out Can You Ever Forgive Me? as I usually like the work of screenwriter Nicole Holofcener.
It's a great script, I think you'd like the movie!
DeleteSome really good mentions. I especially like you giving love to Hawke. How the Academy missed him is beyond me.I also really loved Mulligan in "Wildlife", Willem Dafoe in "At Eternity's Gate", Thomasin McKenzie in "Leave No Trace", Emily Blunt in "A Quiet Place", Joaquin Phoenix in "You Were Never Really Here", John David Washington and Adam Driver in "BlackKklansman". Last year gave us some good performances.
ReplyDeleteI loved Mulligan, she almost makes my Best Actress line up, didn't see Dafoe, wasn't big on Leave no Trace, LOVED Blunt and was a bit meh on Phoenix. Blackkkklansman performances were really good but they miss my line up, I am very happy Driver is nominated, though!
DeleteLOVE your top two, each perfect in their own way. I'm so sad Hawke didn't get an Oscar nomination after practically sweeping all the critics awards. And it's beyond insulting that Cooper continues to lose for the best work of his career to that karaoke night performance of Rami Malek's.
ReplyDeleteLove all of these performances, actually (except Hardy's which I haven't seen), and of course your honorable mention is the TRUE QUEEN of the year. My own list is going to be going up in the next couple of weeks - there was SO much great work this year it's hard to narrow it down!
YEY, cannot wait for your list! I have the most trouble finishing my supporting actresses line up because there were so many great performances last year!
DeleteAMPAS really looks like a bunch of hicks - they snubbed Hawke AND they are probably awarding Malek
When I heard Gaga was attached to A Star is Born, I honestly thought the worst. Boy, what a fool I am! Not only was she absolutely great, but so was the movie! You know my thoughts about that movie, and I'll be rooting for that cast to take home gold...although I'm afraid they won't...it's a shame...
ReplyDeleteI really hope the Academy surprises us and at least Cooper wins. Him losing to Malek would just be horrific
DeleteI am shook. How did I not realise it was the same dog in Game Night and Widows?! Olivia you are an absolute furry legend!
ReplyDeleteYES! She is so versatile! :D
DeleteGreat picks. I was hoping Hawke would be no.1 but kinda knew Cooper would be :P Hopefully I agree with you a few hours from now after seeing it. I like you picked a supporting role too, you are really right in what you said. Coleman was probably my favourite (ha! :P) performance, a few other foreign films had some great ones too.
ReplyDeleteLOVE seeing Hardy there. Anyone else and that movie woulda been awful, he makes it worth watching 100%
Can You Ever Forgive Me, damn I missed that one totally. Worth a watch you think? Looks like a bit of a change of pace for Mellisa.
and I TOTALLY forgot about Blake Lively. Great pick. I'd never even heard of her but she killed it in that movie.
Great picks!
It was very close, I kept switching between Hawke and Cooper but I just love Cooper's songs way too much not to have him as number 1.
DeleteCan You Ever Forgive Me? is still in my top 5 of the year.
You should check out The Town, it's pretty good and it's one of Lively's better roles
The Town.. that was the heist flick from 2010 I think. I'll grab that one, that's two films I've had recommend from you today :)
DeleteTop Five of the year eh? I guess I need to check that out too!
Oh God it was 9 years already since that? :/
DeleteI love this list. Couldn't agree more with your words about supporting performances, and how that applies to Sam Elliott's work in A Star Is Born. And shit, wouldn't it be great if Cooper some how won Best Actor? I would love that.
ReplyDeleteHe would be such a hero if he defeated that abomination that is probably winning
Delete